Skip to main content

Scott Orndorff Retires From Millers Mutual Insurance After Seven Years As President And Ceo, 42 Years In The Industry

By July 30, 2021August 5th, 2021Millers News

Scott A. Orndorff will retire as Vice Chairman and Chief Advisor to the CEO of Millers Mutual Insurance on July 31, 2021, after serving seven years as President & CEO. Orndorff announced his intent to retire in 2019 after 42 years in the industry. He has been serving as Vice Chairman of the Board and Chief Advisor to Jonah Mull, current President & CEO since January 1, 2021, ensuring a smooth and successful transition.

Orndorff served Millers Mutual with great distinction as President & CEO, and as a member of its Board since February 24, 2014. His great concern for the well-being of the Company and its employees reflected his steadfast respect for his colleagues. His strong leadership skills and expertise in strategic planning were instrumental in revolutionizing the Company and setting it up for a very successful future.

“Scott’s dedication to servant leadership, as well as his care and compassion always made others feel respected and valued,” said Jonah Mull, President & CEO. “I look forward to building on the foundation he laid as we continue to challenge ourselves and move this great company into the future.”

Throughout his career, Orndorff held various senior level positions including Senior Executive with Westfield Insurance, where he provided strategic and operational leadership for a specialty division focused on workers compensation, agribusiness and transportation. Prior to that, he was Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer at Old Guard Insurance. He also worked for an insurance agency in Central Pennsylvania, where he was responsible for developing specialty programs and alternative risk transfer mechanisms.

The entire staff and Board wish Scott and his family good health and happiness in his retirement.

Media inquiries should be directed to Katie Gouldner, PR & Marketing Communications Specialist at or 717.480.1696.


Millers Mutual Insurance based in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, is a niche property and casualty insurer serving commercial policyholders in Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia and Washington, D.C., through a network of independent agents. Our mission is simple – we help single and multifamily housing and commercial real estate owners stay in business by protecting them from financial misfortune.  And we do that by offering a full complement of commercial insurance products and services, including Businessowners Policies, Umbrella Liability, Data Cyber, Employment Practices Liability and Equipment Breakdown Insurance.                                                ###