Millers Mutual Insurance Names Jonah Mull as President & Chief Executive Officer Effective January 1, 2021 - Millers Mutual Insurance Skip to main content

Millers Mutual Insurance Names Jonah Mull as President & Chief Executive Officer Effective January 1, 2021

By November 15, 2020Millers News

The Millers Mutual Insurance (Millers) Board of Directors names Jonah Mull, the current Executive Vice President/Chief Operating Officer of Millers to President & Chief Executive Officer effective January 1, 2021.

Team - Jonah MullJonah Mull succeeds Millers Mutual’s current President and CEO Scott Orndorff who announced his intent to retire in 2019 after 42 years in the industry. Orndorff will serve as Vice Chairman of the Board and Chief Advisor to the President/CEO through July 31, 2021, ensuring a smooth and successful transition. On Jonah Mull’s recommendation, Millers Mutual’s Board of Directors has also appointed Jeffrey Pratt, the current Vice President and Chief Financial Officer to Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer effective January 1, 2021.

“The past five years at Millers have been the most exciting of my career,” said Jonah Mull. “The Leadership Team has built a very solid foundation on which to run under Scott Orndorff’s leadership. I am confident in the team here at Millers and look forward to us growing and innovating this great company.”

Jonah Mull will continue to build the Millers Mutual success story with his excellent strategic, operational, and organizational skills. One of his main goals will be executing the company’s 2021-2023 Strategic Plan. A plan he was instrumental in creating.

“Mull has been a significant contributor to the development and successful execution of Millers’ strategic efforts during his tenure with the company,” said Scott Newkam, Board Chairman. The Board looks forward to working with him on the execution of the company’s forward strategy.”

Jonah Mull holds a degree in Insurance and Risk Management from the Penn State University’s Smeal College of Business and has over 20 years of experience in the insurance industry. He joined Millers in 2014 as an Underwriting Leader responsible for the growth, profit, and development of the Underwriting Teams. He quickly shifted into the role of Vice President of Operations in 2017, where he focused on overseeing pricing, product development, filing/rates/rules, quality assurance and policy services. In November of 2019, the Board of Directors appointed Jonah to Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer.

Media inquiries should be directed to Karen Anuscavage, Vice President Human Resources, at or 1.800.745.4555.